Gomestic > Family

To Spank or Not to Spank

Questions on spanking and their results. would love to hear others opinions

There is a question that comes into the life of every parent; do you spank or not spank your child? I wonder if it is possible to be a quasi-advocate for spanking, because that is exactly where my opinion lays on this subject. My stance is squarely on the middle of the fence; somewhere that I really do not find myself very often.

I know I was spanked as a child, not beaten, but spanked when the situation clearly called for it. I have met and talked to others who were hit beyond spanking; with a belt or a switch for instance. This is clearly above and beyond in my mind. I am not an advocate for abusing a child, or inflicting any kind of pain. In my mind a spanking is a physical act that gives a child kind of a mental head slap that lets them know that what they are doing is beyond their typical simple wrongdoing.

In the past three years I have been the parent of a seventeen-month old, a sixteen year old, a five year old, a three year old, and a six-month old. Now, I am not living in a situation like the movie, “Your, Mine and Ours” or any sort of “Brady Bunch.” I am a foster and adoptive parent.

As such my husband and I have signed papers certifying that we will not spank any foster or adoptive child put into our care by the great state of Connecticut . Some of the time this is very easy, kids have always seemed so innocent and honest to me.

I have never been so wrong in my entire life, my five year old daughter will lie about absolutely anything and for no other reason that she wants too. It makes me crazy. She also rolls her eyes at me, screams when things don't know her way, sucks her teeth, and argues with every word that comes out of my mouth. Now if that is not a cause for spanking I am not sure what is. But, I swear that my husband and I have not spanked her. We have both had the opportunity to want to spank her, but neither of us have done it.

Lately, my three-year old foster son also seems to be asking for a spanking, yelling at me, hitting me, and throwing tantrums that rattle the walls. For those I am simply going to invest in ear plugs.

The question remains though; to spank or not to spank. Does violence beget violence, or does a small spanking teach a child that something as harmful as playing with matches is something that has dire consequences.

I guess time will tell if my children will turn into respectable and responsible members of society without a spanking here or there to get their attention

0
Liked It
I Like It!
Related Articles
To Spank or Not to Spank  |  In Front of God and Man: Spanking Discipline in Public
More Articles by Maura Clegg
The Perfect Tantrum  |  Bribery, It's the answer
Latest Articles in Family
Blessings: Big and Small  |  Father's Day
Comments (2)
#1 by Ric Dube, Jan 7, 2007
This is a sore subjuect for me. I feel one of the reasons kids are so out of control these days are due to the fact that you can't give them a little spank or crack when the situation calls for it. I also am not advocating any beatings. But when a child can call a government agency on his or her own parents for taking control within the 4 walls of their home, makes for a sad state of affairs.
#2 by B.Adlaon, Jan 8, 2007
There should definitely be a clarification on the difference between "beating" and "spanking". I definitely spank my children. Thank goodness, it is not illegal to do that in the Philippines, although child-beating is. Many people say my child is better behaved--and happier, too--than most other kids.

And as for spanking teaching children to be violent, I've seen way too many kids who were NOT spank but are violent, nonetheless.
Post Your Comment:
Name:  
Copy the code into this box:  
Inside Gomestic

Apartment Living

 /

Consumer Information

 /

Cooking

 /

Do-It-Yourself

 /

Emergency Preparation

 /

Entertaining

 /

Family

 /

Gardening

 /

Home

 /

Home Business

 /

Home Improvement

 /

Homemaking

 /

Homeowners

 /

Moving

 /

Personal Finance

 /

Personal Organization

 /

Pets

 /

Rural Living


Popular Tags
Popular Writers
Gomestic
About Us
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Services
Submit an Article
Advertise with Us
Contact

© 2007 Copyright Stanza Ltd. All Rights Reserved.