Gomestic > Apartment Living

Does This Make Sense

Something to ponder... is it sensible?

The Jones family has been living in an apartment complex for almost ten years. They have been good tenants and have been late with their rent once. The apartment has not been painted or the carpet changed within those ten years. When the Jones moved in, they had a dog and two cats. They were told the dog had to go but, the cats were ok.

The apartment complex over the past ten years has had over ten managers and each manager knew about the Jones' cats. In those ten years, tile has come off the kitchen floor. The tile in the bathroom is up and curled over, the bathtub has been slathered with something almost every year to keep it from leaking on the tenants below and the smoke detector is hanging by the wires. In those ten years the heating system has never worked, in fact causing the smoke detector to go off when it is turned on.

Mrs. Jones was putting away dishes from out of the dishwasher, she stepped back from the level floor into the section that had no tile and her back popped, causing pain and numbness in her left leg. This transpired in 2006, it is now 2007. The Jones family wants the apartment repaired. The manager agreed telling the family they would have to move their belongings out and find a place to stay for five days. Which wasn't possible, because of finances (if they could have afforded that they would have moved in the first place) and it just plain didn't make sense.

There were three apartments available in the same complex, one right across the hall. The manager was asked if the family could move into another apartment and they could go ahead and repair the old one (which made sense). The manager said she would have to talk to the regional manager.

When the manager was asked if the move was ok, the Family was told no because they had cats. Now mind you, it is ok for them to stay in the apartment that needs repairs and pay rent and, keep their cats. They have never been asked to get rid of the animals. The manager decided to set up a day for the floor to be repaired, that means the Jones family will have to put some of their belongings on the patio, for how long? No one knows.

When she was told it would have made better sense if they'd let them move to another apartment, she replied they couldn't allow the family to move to another apartment with the cats, they had a no pet policy...

1
Liked It
I Like It!
Related Articles
Does Child Support Make Sense?  |  A Practice in Perspective By a Parent with Parkinson's
More Articles by m.l. davis
Let Me Be Me
Latest Articles in Apartment Living
Winter  |  Healing for the Heart
Comments (7)
#1 by Allergic to cats, Dec 2, 2007
maybe I'm extra-sensible because, while I like cats, I can't be around them. I understand why the manager doesn't want the cats in other apartments. My suggestions: kennel the cats, have the cats sit with a friend, give the cats away. "If you haven't got your health, you haven't got anything." That saying has nothing in it about cats. If it comes down to your family's health and well-being or the comfort of your pets and you can't decide, you have other problems.
#2 by m.l. davis, Dec 4, 2007
if you have comments, that is fine post them, but before you do, please read carefully, if you don't understand ask me..don't be like (allergic to cats) the (extra-sensible) one..
thank you
m.l. davis
#3 by mimi, Dec 6, 2007
I thought that the comment by "Allergic to Cats" was fair game and didn't indicate any incomprehension of the story.

With that said, I can totally understand that after 10 years, the Jones would want their apartment repaired and I think it's reasonable for the management to comply and at the same time ask the family to move out for 5 days. There are a lot of repairs needed and 5 days is short amount of time to get all that stuff done. If they were home owners and needed that extent of repairs, the same would apply -- they would have to move out.

I also understand how the management would not want the new apartment exposed to cat dander, as some people are very sensitive to it and remain allergic to it long after the source of the dander (the cat) is gone.

And if the building has a no pet policy, it's probably out of the good graces of the management (and out of respect for the tenants for having been good tenants for 10 years), that they have not been asked to get rid of their cats.

All this should really be written up in a new lease, though.
#4 by K.A., Mar 13, 2008
A kennel? Do you know how expensive that can get? And not everyone has friends who are available to pet-sit. Keep in mind, if this family has lived under slum lords like this they probably are very financially disadvantaged.
I would hope there was something illegal about forcing tenants to live in an apartment where the tub leaks and the smoke alarm isn\'t fully installed. If not, there is definitely a moral issue. If it\'s an issue of code violation, the landlord should be liable for finding temporary housing for the tenants.
#5 by baltimore dweller, Mar 15, 2008
My building was recently purchased by a new landlord and before renewing each of our leases, he renovated/made improvements on all of the apartments. In some cases this was simply a coat of paint and in others it was more major renovations. My fiance and I had to be relocated for one month along with our cats. Since it was through no fault of our own AND since our current lease allowed for cats it was his responsibility to house us and our cats for the month, regardless of the terms of any other lease in the building. We continued to pay our rent and he gave us access to an another apartment and a locked storage unit for our stuff (the temporary apartment was small) for the month while they worked on our apartment. If they are not willing to house her in one of their properties then they need to put her in a hotel that allows pets or pay her kennel fees. This is the normal way things are handled.

Unfortunately, if a landlord is content to allow an apartment to fall into this kind of disrepair, he probably isn't a very considerate landlord. Isn't their a housing authority that can be contacted? Your friend might even benefit from speaking with a lawyer... Not knowing all of the specifics, I can't be positive, but it is possible that the landlord could also be liable for her doctor's bills, lost wages(if she had to miss time from work) and so forth
#6 by mel, Jun 22, 2008
They were told the dog had to go and they got rid of him/her??
Anyone who could do that, instead of just moving, doesn't get
any sympathy from me for anything. Breeders should have
to "get rid of" their screaming destructive germ-ridden brats.
#7 by alohainoc, Jun 25, 2008
i think that something called "customer service" should be considered in this situation. I dont see any reason why they would not just move them to another apartment.

i am being forced out of my apartment for major repairs. They are resending the offer for another apartment and are now offering to place me in a hotel during the repairs. Is this really all they are required to do? make me live out of a suitcase? am i legally allowed to break my lease? does anyone know? or know who i can contact with my questions. Im in south california
Post Your Comment:
Name:  
Copy the code into this box:  
Inside Gomestic

Apartment Living

 /

Consumer Information

 /

Cooking

 /

Do-It-Yourself

 /

Emergency Preparation

 /

Entertaining

 /

Family

 /

Gardening

 /

Home

 /

Home Business

 /

Home Improvement

 /

Homemaking

 /

Homeowners

 /

Moving

 /

Personal Finance

 /

Personal Organization

 /

Pets

 /

Rural Living


Popular Tags
Popular Writers
Gomestic
About Us
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Services
Submit an Article
Advertise with Us
Contact

© 2007 Copyright Stanza Ltd. All Rights Reserved.